Kill it or keep it

A feature that is neither clearly working nor clearly dead.

We are deciding whether to keep investing in this feature. Give me the case for killing it, the case for keeping it, then your own call. Judge it on what it does for users now, not on what we hoped it would do when we built it.

Feature, and the numbers I have:

Prioritising and scope. Deciding what makes the cut and what the plan actually is: backlogs, MVPs, estimates, roadmaps.